Charges dropped against boy, 12, over Sunshine death

DPP advice found no reasonable prospects of conviction, citing the legal presumption that children aged 12 or 13 are not criminally responsible

Charges laid against a 12-year-old boy over the fatal assault of a man in Sunshine have been withdrawn, police say.

Police confirmed this afternoon that charges of intentionally cause serious injury, intentionally cause injury and affray were withdrawn “after significant consideration”.

Police say advice from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) confirmed there were no reasonable prospects of conviction against the accused. The advice cited the presumption at law that a child aged 12 or 13 is not criminally responsible for their actions.

The charges relate to an incident in Sunshine on 1 August, in which a 60-year-old Sunshine West man was fatally assaulted. Police say he was taken to hospital, where he “sadly died” on 5 August.

The Homicide Squad conducted what police describe as a thorough investigation. Melton Crime Investigation Unit charged five young people over the incident: three boys aged 12, 13 and 15 from the Brimbank area, a 14-year-old girl from the Banyule area and a 14-year-old girl from the Brimbank area.

They were charged with affray, violent disorder, intentionally cause serious injury and intentionally cause injury.

Police say the 15-year-old boy’s charges were later upgraded to include manslaughter. Further investigations exonerated the 13-year-old boy, and his charges were withdrawn.

Police said it would be “inappropriate to comment further” as the matter remains before the court.

They said the victim’s family has been notified and will continue to be supported throughout the process. “Our thoughts are with them today,” police said.