Fifteen years after Brenda Goudge was murdered at her Wantirna South home, her family is still waiting for the answers they have never received — and they say they will not stop asking.
Knox News sat down with Brenda’s sister, Sue McCormack, for an exclusive interview as the family continues its public plea for information.
Brenda was 61 when she was found dead in July 2011. Police believe she was murdered. Fifteen years on, no-one has been convicted over her death.
“Give it up. Do the right thing. Clear your conscience, because every night you close your eyes, you will see her lying in the pool, not having justice,” Sue said.
A Family That Refuses to Stop Asking
For fifteen years, Brenda’s family has continued calling on anyone with information to come forward — no matter how long ago they may have heard it, or how insignificant they believe it to be.
That determination has driven Sue to search for answers herself. She said she has gone back through the case documents again and again, refusing to let it go cold.
“It’s just so frustrating. I’ve read through 3,200 pages of the inquest three times, hoping that I can find something that’ll get some answers,” she said.
A coronial inquest in 2016 examined the circumstances of Brenda’s death, but the coroner was unable to determine who was responsible. A person previously identified by police as a prime suspect, Paul Callaway. Could not be positively excluded — but no charge has ever followed, and the case remains open.

“We Won’t Give Up”
Despite the years without a breakthrough, and a reward of up to $1 million still on offer for information leading to a conviction, Sue is adamant the case has never been about money.
“The smartest officer in the Cold Case Squad, you get in there, you pick up her file, you read it, and you can have the reward,” she said.
For Brenda’s family, it has always been about Brenda — and the years that have passed without justice.
“That we’re still trying. We won’t give up. I will never give up,” Sue said.
Living With the Unanswered Questions
Fifteen years of unanswered questions have taken a deeply personal toll on Sue. She said she once experienced recurring nightmares of someone standing beside her bed — and has since come to wonder whether they echoed something Brenda herself may have gone through.
“I used to have terrible nightmares that someone was standing beside the bed,” Sue said.
“And now I think that that’s a nightmare that she had to live through. You know, because I know it used to frighten me at the time.”
Still Waiting, Still Asking
Fifteen years have passed, but Brenda’s family has never stopped searching for answers. They are still asking the same question: who knows what happened to Brenda Goudge?
Anyone with information about Brenda’s death is urged to contact Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000. Information can also be provided anonymously online through Crime Stoppers Victoria.
A reward of up to $1 million is available for information leading to the apprehension and conviction of the person responsible.