Community Campaign Secures Green Wedge Victory
The Lysterfield Valley Green Wedge has received a major environmental victory after VCAT upheld Yarra Ranges Council’s refusal of a controversial clean fill proposal.
The application sought permission to deposit approximately 400,000 cubic metres of clean fill across 15 hectares.
The works would have occurred over three years. However, the tribunal agreed the proposal should not proceed.
As a result, years of campaigning by residents, environmental organisations and Yarra Ranges Council delivered a significant outcome.
The decision protects one of Melbourne’s most valued landscapes.
Valley Holds Long-Recognised Heritage Value
The National Trust’s Dandenong Ranges Branch noted the Lysterfield Valley has remained a National Trust Classified Landscape since 1981.
Additionally, opponents argued the proposal threatened protected Green Wedge land, productive agricultural areas and the valley’s distinctive landscape character.
Earlier planning documents also identified concerns about vegetation, waterways and increased traffic.
Furthermore, opponents questioned the proposal’s long-term impact on the valley’s landscape.
Knox Council’s Limited Role Draws Criticism
Despite sharing a municipal boundary with the valley, Knox City Council did not lodge a formal objection.
Instead, councillors later agreed to send a letter supporting Yarra Ranges Council.
However, they did so after public submissions had already closed.
The decision followed sustained pressure from community members.
Moreover, Knox Council resolved in October 2023 that it would “not participate in any appeal or legal proceedings on this matter.”
That position has since attracted criticism from some residents.
They believe Knox should have taken a stronger role in protecting the neighbouring Green Wedge.
Years of Advocacy Finally Rewarded
Meanwhile, community groups maintained sustained opposition throughout the planning and tribunal process.
The campaign included the Knox Environment Society, Save the Dandenong’s League, local residents and Yarra Ranges Council.
Consequently, supporters say the decision protects an environmentally significant landscape for future generations.
VCAT ultimately found the proposal failed to deliver a net community benefit and upheld Yarra Ranges Council’s original refusal.
